From September 1998 to 2002 TMC published, somewhat regularly, official staff reviews. Some attempts were made to revitalize an official TMC reviews center over the years that followed and in 2009 the idea was officially shelved. Below you will find the reviews that were posted during those 11 years.

Although the site-sponsored review system no longer exists many of the muds listed in the TMC database allow their userbase to submit 'player' reviews. To check if a listed mud has player-supplied reviews have a look at its TMC mud listing.

4 Dimensions - Review Written January 8, 2009 Materia Magica - Review Written December 17, 2007 SlothMUD - Review Written April 14, 2003 DragonStone - Review Written October 30, 2002 The X-Files MUCK - Review Written August 19, 2002 Legends Untold - Review Written July 30, 2002 Dragon's Fang - Review Written October 11, 2001 Realms of Despair - Review Written July 5, 2001 Urath - Review Written January 26, 2001 Wheel of Time - Review Written November 16, 2000 Necromium - Review Written August 20, 2000 Haven Lpmud - Review Written July 13, 2000 Ansalon - Review Written May 25, 2000 The Inquisition - Review Written February 25, 2000 Teenagers From Outer Space MUX (TFOS) - Review Written January 11, 2000 Carrion Fields - Review Written December 10, 1999 CyberASSAULT - Review Written October 19, 1999 After the Plague - Review Written September 28, 1999 Thanatos - Review Written July 18, 1999 Dragon Swords - Review Written July 3, 1999 Lensmoor - Review Written June 27, 1999 MUME - Multi Users In Middle Earth - Review Written May 30, 1999 Castle of the Exiles - Review Written April 24, 1999 Sleepless Nights - Review Written April 13, 1999 Age of War - Review Written March 27, 1999 3-Kingdoms - Review Written March 14, 1999 Malevolence - Review Written February 25, 1999 KoBra - Review Written February 17, 1999 Sojourn - Review Written February 7, 1999 Threshold RPG - Review Written January 22, 1999 Royal Training: DreamScape - Review Written December 14, 1998 Rehobaom's Legacy - Review Written December 6, 1998 Hidden Worlds - Review Written November 30, 1998 Allusia: The Web of Deception - Review Written November 19, 1998 Babylon 5: The Last Best Hope - Review Written November 10, 1998 Basternae - Review Written October 31, 1998 Abandoned Realms - Review Written October 17, 1998 Waterdeep - Review Written September 29, 1998